Mariah Carey’s Brother Morgan Carey Intensifies Legal Battle Against the Pop Icon
In a dramatic turn of events, Morgan Carey, the brother of pop superstar Mariah Carey, is not backing down in his ongoing legal fight against his sister. The 60-year-old has sought to amend his lawsuit, aiming to include additional claims of "defamatory" statements made by Mariah in her memoir, "The Meaning of Mariah Carey." This legal saga has not only highlighted the complexities of their familial relationship but also brought to light the emotional turmoil that often accompanies public disputes among family members.
Fresh Allegations and Legal Maneuvers
Morgan’s legal battle began in 2021 when he accused Mariah of defamation, claiming that her memoir contained damaging statements about him. Recently, he has requested the court’s permission to amend his lawsuit, asserting that he has discovered new evidence of "false, disparaging, and defamatory" remarks made by Mariah, some of which he claims to have found on YouTube. This fresh evidence is pivotal as it could potentially reshape the legal landscape of their dispute.
In her memoir, Mariah portrayed Morgan in a negative light, alleging that he was involved in violent behavior and drug dealing—claims that Morgan vehemently denies. He argues that he was never given an opportunity to respond to these allegations before they were published, which he believes is a fundamental violation of his rights.
Shocking Claims from the Memoir
One of the most controversial claims in Mariah’s memoir involves an incident from 1980, where she alleges that Morgan accepted money from a woman to kill her husband but later backed out. The woman subsequently committed the murder, and Morgan testified at her trial. This particular allegation has been a focal point in Morgan’s lawsuit, as he insists it is not only false but also deeply damaging to his reputation.
The YouTube Documentary Controversy
Morgan’s lawsuit extends beyond the memoir, as he is also targeting a YouTube documentary that surfaced in 2025, which has garnered over 220,000 views. In this documentary, Mariah makes explosive accusations, claiming that her family attempted to institutionalize her and control her life during a critical period in her career. Morgan interprets her statements as direct references to him and their mother, Patricia, and he argues that these claims are not only untrue but also defamatory.
He has labeled Mariah’s assertions as "a vicious lie," emphasizing that neither he nor their mother ever sought to have Mariah institutionalized or gain control over her finances. This aspect of the case underscores the deep-seated family tensions that have been exacerbated by public scrutiny.
Court-Ordered Depositions Amid Family Tragedy
In a significant ruling, a judge has ordered both Mariah and Morgan to participate in court-ordered depositions, compelling them to confront each other despite their long-standing estrangement. This ruling came shortly after the siblings faced a devastating family loss, with both their mother and sister passing away on the same day in August. The emotional weight of this tragedy adds another layer of complexity to their legal battle.
Mariah publicly expressed her grief over the loss of her mother and sister, stating, "My heart is broken that I’ve lost my mother this past weekend. Sadly, in a tragic turn of events, my sister lost her life on the same day." This heartfelt acknowledgment of their family tragedy highlights the personal stakes involved in their ongoing dispute.
A Complicated Mother-Daughter Relationship
Mariah’s relationship with her mother, Patricia, was fraught with challenges, a theme she explored in her memoir. Mariah described their bond as complex, shaped by her parents’ divorce when she was just three years old. Despite their tumultuous history, Mariah spent the last week of Patricia’s life by her side, indicating a reconciliation of sorts. In her memoir, she reflected on their relationship, acknowledging the contradictions and emotional complexities that defined it.
Alison Carey’s Legal Action
The family dynamics further complicate the situation, as Mariah’s late sister, Alison Carey, also took legal action against her over claims made in the memoir. Alison accused Mariah of public humiliation and sought $1.25 million in damages, describing the statements as "heartless, vicious, vindictive, despicable, and totally unnecessary." This lawsuit underscores the ongoing familial rifts that have been exacerbated by Mariah’s public persona and the revelations in her memoir.
The Ongoing Legal Battle
With Morgan Carey’s recent legal maneuvers, it is clear that his battle against Mariah Carey is far from over. As both siblings prepare to face each other in court, the outcome of this legal dispute remains uncertain. The intersection of family loyalty, public perception, and personal grievances continues to play out in a very public arena, leaving fans and observers alike to ponder the complexities of familial relationships in the shadow of fame.