Mobile Wallets, Regulatory Advances, and Innovation Propel Fintech Sector into Digital Future

The Transformation of Pakistan’s Fintech Landscape

The fintech industry in Pakistan is experiencing a significant transformation, driven by local entrepreneurs who are encouraged to develop their own payment systems instead of relying on international giants like PayPal and Stripe. Monis Rahman, CEO of Dukan and Chairman of Rozee, emphasizes the importance of independence in this sector. He asserts, “We have the talent and ability today to build our own bridges and PayPals. It seems like a waste of time to wait for PayPal and Stripe when our fintech entrepreneurs should be focusing on building our own rails so we are independent of international whims that can hijack our digitisation agenda.”

Cybersecurity Awareness in the Digital Age

As the digital landscape expands, so does the risk of cybercrimes. Rahman highlights the necessity of educating consumers about basic cybersecurity principles to protect against social engineering fraud. He acknowledges the learning curve faced by the first digital generation, noting that while fraud will always be a concern, effective measures can be implemented to minimize risks. The goal is to ensure that the benefits of fintech far outweigh its potential drawbacks.

Innovative Solutions from Local Fintechs

One of the standout success stories in Pakistan’s fintech sector is Abhi, which has introduced innovative solutions like Earned Wage Access (EWA). Mohammad Sultan Zaidi, Chief Commercial Officer of Abhi, stresses the importance of identifying and addressing consumer problems. He points out that many service providers often try to fit preconceived solutions to consumer needs, which can lead to failure. “A successful company not only strengthens the economy but also benefits individuals,” he states, underscoring the need for tailored products that effectively solve real issues.

The Importance of Profitability

Zaidi also warns against the common pitfall of startups that focus solely on network expansion without prioritizing profitability from the outset. This short-sighted approach often leads to business collapse, highlighting the necessity of sustained profitability for long-term success in the fintech landscape.

Opportunities in a Large Unbanked Population

Pakistan’s substantial unbanked and underbanked population presents significant opportunities for fintech growth. Shahzad Shahid, Group CEO of TPS Worldwide, emphasizes that fintechs offering specialized services for specific customer segments are crucial for increasing cashless payments. He notes that the regulatory focus on financial inclusion acknowledges that commercial banks alone cannot achieve this transformation. The success of fintech hinges on scalable, cost-effective technology and a deep understanding of end-user preferences.

Regulatory Environment and Business Climate

The prosperity of the fintech industry is closely tied to improvements in the overall business climate. Shahid points out the need for centralized economic documentation for policymakers and increased access to fintech from banks. He also highlights the importance of RAAST’s commitment to delivering low-cost, widely accepted digital payments.

Diverse Landscape of Fintech in 2023

In 2023, Pakistan’s fintech sector showcased a diverse landscape. Some operators focused on profitability, while others, including major players, retracted their plans amid economic challenges. Innovators like ABHI and Finja thrived, with ABHI’s advanced salary service gaining popularity. Conversely, global names like Checkout and CareemPay withdrew their licenses, opting out of the local market. Analyst Muhammad Yasir suggests that fintechs should focus on tailored solutions for agriculture, SMEs, retailers, and overseas Pakistanis, advocating for collaboration over competition.

Distinguishing Fintech from Branchless Banking

It’s essential to distinguish between fintech and branchless banking (BB). Fintech encompasses a wide array of financial use cases, including payments, banking, insurance, e-commerce, lending, and wallets. Leading fintech companies in Pakistan include Abhi, Sadapay, Bazaar, Finja, Haball, and Keenu. In contrast, branchless banking, exemplified by services like EasyPaisa, JazzCash, and UBL Omni, focuses on providing banking services through agent networks.

Challenges Facing the Fintech Sector

Despite its growth, the burgeoning fintech sector faces various challenges. Regulatory hurdles, including time-consuming approvals and compliance processes, make initiation and operation slower and more expensive than for other startups. Once established, these ventures often encounter untapped potential due to inadequate bank support and customer reluctance to pay for services. Intense price competition in a substantial grey market further complicates the landscape.

Funding Constraints and Traditional Mindsets

Fintech companies are also grappling with funding constraints stemming from global instability. A lingering traditional mindset and a lack of corporate culture can hinder seamless evolution. Clients face network disruptions, inflation-related concerns, and a reliance on two networks, Raast and 1Link. Cash remains the preferred method for regular payments, which hinders the broader adoption of online payment solutions. Challenges such as limited connectivity, add-on fees, and security concerns further impede fintech’s acceptance.

Future Opportunities in Fintech

Despite these challenges, opportunities abound in Pakistan’s fintech sector, particularly for innovative products that are not yet available in the local market. The future outlook emphasizes a shift towards technology as consumers increasingly seek convenience and quick solutions over traditional banking methods. The gradual transition from cash withdrawals to digital payments marks a significant milestone for Pakistan’s digital economy.

Pivotal Developments in the Digital Economy

Three key developments are poised to propel Pakistan’s digital economy through fintech. Firstly, the State Bank of Pakistan’s introduction of RAAST Person-to-Merchant (P2M) payments empowers small merchants to receive payments instantly in their bank accounts. This system, inspired by successful models in India (UPI) and Brazil (PIX), is expected to drive exponential growth in digital payments.

Secondly, several new license categories now allow for open banking connectivity for startups. This shift enables the development of banking and financial apps using licenses from banking partners, promising to expedite innovation by leveraging the agility of fintech operations.

Lastly, a notable shift in the ecosystem sees banks adopting a more collaborative attitude towards fintechs. This departure from the previous walled-garden approach fosters a healthier, more dynamic relationship between traditional financial institutions and fintech innovators, contributing to overall ecosystem growth.

Rapid Evolution of Fintech in Less Than a Decade

In less than a decade, Pakistan’s fintech sector has undergone rapid and substantial evolution. The rise of mobile wallets, which now account for 90% of new accounts, reflects this transformative impact. Today, a majority of Pakistani adults possess Internet-connected smartphones, marking widespread access to technology. Notably, digital payments have surged nine-fold over the past three years.

Role of Regulatory Bodies

The proactive roles of the State Bank of Pakistan and the Securities Exchange Commission of Pakistan have been pivotal in steering this evolution. Their collaborative efforts, involving various licenses and private sector participation, have empowered fintechs to identify lucrative avenues and refine business models based on practical learnings, resulting in a dynamic evolution of the fintech landscape.

For more insights and updates, follow Business on Facebook and @TribuneBiz on Twitter.